Skip to product information
1 of 3

Lemon Squares

Regular price
$30.00
Regular price
Sale price
$30.00
Shipping calculated at checkout.

ToffeeSmyth has perfected Uncle Archibald’s 1968 Lemon Squares recipe for a modern twist on a classic favorite. Each delicate square sits atop a buttery English shortbread crust and bursts with the bright, fresh flavor of freshly squeezed lemons. The perfect balance of tart and sweet makes every bite irresistible.

What it is

ToffeeSmyth has refined Uncle Archibald’s 1968 Lemon Squares, preserving their classic foundation while elevating them for a modern palate. Each square features a rich, buttery English shortbread crust topped with a smooth layer of filling made from freshly squeezed lemons. The result is a clean, balanced profile of bright citrus and gentle sweetness, offering an elegant take on a timeless dessert.

Why you’ll love it

● Bright, fresh citrus flavor made with freshly squeezed lemons
● Buttery English shortbread crust that provides a rich, tender base
● Perfect balance of tartness and gentle sweetness
● Smooth, clean texture with a refined finish
● Small-batch craftsmanship for consistent quality
● Elegant, versatile dessert suited for gifting, entertaining, or everyday enjoyment
● Classic recipe elevated with a modern, polished execution

Perfect for

Gifting & celebrations
● Holiday gatherings and seasonal celebrations
● Hostess gifts and thoughtful thank-you gestures
● Corporate gifting and client appreciation
● Weddings, showers, and special events
● Dessert tables and catered functions
● Afternoon tea, coffee service, or light dessert offerings
● Everyday indulgence and home entertaining
● Curated gift boxes and specialty food assortments

Everyday enjoyment & entertaining
● As a light afternoon treat with coffee or tea
● Served as a simple after-dinner dessert
● Paired with fresh berries or seasonal fruit for an easy plate
● Enjoyed chilled for a firmer, more refreshing texture
● Shared casually at home with family or guests
● Included in lunchboxes or midday breaks for a bright, citrus finish
● Plated simply for an effortless, elegant everyday indulgence

Retail & hospitality
● In-room amenity or turndown treat in hotels and resorts
● Part of afternoon tea or dessert service menus
● Banquet and catering dessert for weddings and events
● Individually plated portions for private dining experiences
● Pre-packaged retail dessert for grab-and-go counters
● Featured item in gourmet or specialty food shops
● Part of curated gift boxes and seasonal assortments
● Sold in boxes and individually wrapped bars for convenience and freshness
● Inclusion in holiday, corporate, or hostess gift collections
● Upscale bakery case item for cafés and boutique bakeries

Texture & flavor profile

Texture:
● Buttery, tender shortbread base with a fine, delicate crumb
● Smooth, custard-like lemon layer that sets cleanly when sliced
● Lightly firm yet melt-in-the-mouth top layer
● Clean cut edges for a structured, polished presentation

Flavor Profile:
● Bright, natural citrus from freshly squeezed lemons and zest
● Balanced tartness that leads the flavor profile without overwhelming
● Gentle, rounded sweetness that softens the acidity
● Rich, buttery undertone from the shortbread crust
● Clean, refreshing finish with lingering lemon brightness

Overall Experience:
A well-balanced contrast of rich, buttery depth and vibrant citrus clarity, offering a refined take on a classic lemon dessert.

Ingredients

Lemon juice, sugar, butter, flour, eggs, lemon zest
Contains: Dairy, eggs, gluten

Product details

● Format: Dessert
● Category: Artisan Dessert Bars / Gourmet bakery item
● Handmade in Small batches

Made in Charleston, SC by 6th generation Charlestonians

A premium, handcrafted dessert bar that elevates a traditional lemon square through refined ingredients, balanced flavor, and consistent artisanal production.

Storage & shelf life

● Store in a cool dark place, preferably refrigerated or frozen for freshness
● Shelf life: up to 2 weeks refrigerated, 2–3 months frozen

Good to know

● Ships fresh and carefully packaged
● Best enjoyed at room temperature

ToffeeSmyth schedules shipments for these items exclusively on Mondays, Tuesdays, or Wednesdays to maintain freshness upon delivery.

Orders made after Wednesday will be scheduled for shipment on the following Monday.

Lemon Squares
Lemon Squares

FAQs

Do Lemon Squares need to be refrigerated?
Yes. For best freshness and texture, we recommend storing them refrigerated or frozen.
How long do they last?
They can be stored for up to 2 weeks in the refrigerator and 2–3 months in the freezer.
Are they a good gift?
Lemon Squares make an exceptional gift. Crafted with premium ingredients and a meticulous, small-batch approach, they offer a refined and memorable option for any occasion—from intimate gatherings with family and friends to holiday celebrations and corporate gifting.
Do they contain nuts or allergens?
Yes. These pies contain pecans (tree nuts), dairy, eggs, and gluten.
When is the best way to serve them?
They are best at room temperature or warmed up in the oven, and pair perfectly with coffee, espresso and ice cream.
Shipments
ToffeeSmyth schedules shipments for these items exclusively on Mondays, Tuesdays, or Wednesdays to maintain freshness upon delivery.

Orders made after Wednesday will be scheduled for shipment on the following Monday.